65 Tuthill Road (Google Map, GPS)
On Rt. 27, in the heart of town you’ll find the circular “plaza”. Make a left at either end of the
leftsemi-circle and then take the only road off the circle, Edgemere Road.
-Follow Edgemere Road past a body of water on your left (Fort Pond), and Montauk Surf Lodge.
Past the water you’ll see a car repair shop, the LIRR station, and Depot Art Gallery . Turn left at
The Old Harbor House, a white one-story restaurant. (On your right you’ll see the Montauk Fire
Department and the Community Center)
-Turn right at the stop sign.
-Follow Tuthill Road past Rough Riders Condominiums.
-On your left you’ll see a fence with a large gate. This is Millionaire’s Row! You’ll notice two green oars with the address 132B Tuthill Road on them.
– Park in the grassy area across the street from the fence. Or, if you’re staying at First Cottage, park in your own private spot right in front of the cottage.